in ,

The Good and The Bad of Jeremy Corbyn

Corbyn wasn’t proposing state socialism. He was planning nationalisation of key natural monopolies only – power, water, post office, transport, and broadband.

Submitted by Mousumi Roy…

As expected Conservatives under populist Johnson trounced Labor under Corbyn. The conservative candidate who won even seemed a little surprised himself. The BoJo-ites are not perfect. Brexit on road with many economical pitfalls. Scotland will most probably go its own way. Scottish Nationalist party SNP swept the election in Scotland. Will watch for moves in Northern Ireland and Welsh for separation from UK. Over the last 2 decades the demography of UK had undergone a huge change. The voting pattern of Urban centers like London and Manchester is totally different from the countryside. This dichotomy of thought and perception is not good.

Corbyn wasn’t proposing state socialism. He was planning nationalisation of key natural monopolies only – power, water, post office, transport, and broadband. In the 70’s, had a collapsing manufacturing base which governments of both stripes tried ineptly to bail out. That’s not the case at the moment.

Labour in the 90’s and early 2000s took a Keynesian approach, which notable success up until the global financial crisis. Brown should have repaid more debt during his second financially positive period, but he nonetheless  ran surpluses and reduced debt using a keynesian model. There are many things about that government’s conduct that People disagree with; involving the private sector to make things happen in a hurry meant large unnecessary costs and a lack of really solid institutions, so the tories have been able to tear it down very quickly. They should have reversed some of the tories financial market deregulation, but instead they continued on that course.

NHM is a socialist plan sucessfully implemented in UK .

Any Progressive nation with high level human development/happiness indices are socialist in nature be it Scandivian countries or Holland etc.

The global financial crisis resulted from the deregulation, not from the short term actions of any one party in any one country. Keynesian economics, on the broad pallet, works. Austerity doesn’t, at least it doesn’t work on the basis that it was presented, as a means to sort out national finances. As a narrative to remove the public services that normal people rely on while enriching the already rich, it was a great success.

The tories have been touching the NHS. It’s on its knees. The industries to be nationalised are services that every citizen requires, and they should not be generating profits. The proposed taxation is not “very high” even by current European standards. Now the NHS is partly privatised, has been horribly underfunded, and is under threat of being put up for sale. They’ve starved it so that it looks like it doesn’t work, and after Brexit, there’s every indication that it will be sold off in large part to American corporate healthcare firms.

Lots of European countries run nationalised industries with decent success. Look at what Boris was PROMISING manifesto. The removal of judicial oversight, the shackling of the Lords, severe erosion of democracy. You are guessing that a man who had worked hard his entire life as a constituency MP and peace activist is going to turn into a totalitarian when in office, and therefore someone who is promising authoritarian reforms seemed like a bad bet.

4 years ago Portugal kicked out their austerity-loving conservatives, and voted in a socialist govt who promised to end austerity (to the absolute horror of the bankers).

The result? The fastest economic growth this century, above the EU average for 8 straight quarters. Unemployment has halved. The place is alive with concerts and art that was nowhere to be seen 10 years ago. They’re raising the minimum wage in January.

Boris Johnson will mean Brexit. They  will leave on the 31st of January, without a credible deal, with no trade agreement in place. Boris Johnson also means, according to the Tory manifesto, the removal of many of the legal checks and balances which protect their democracy, such as judicial oversight and the power of the House of Lords.  What you’ll get will be another 4 years of economic stagnation and rising debt. The rich and corporations will continue to pay the low taxes they are currently on, and you will get a tiny tax cut. Your services, healthcare, social care, libraries, sure start centres, homeless support, housing, they’re already gone, with no credible plan to replace them. 1000’s more people will die from tory cuts.

“Everyone knows” Corbyn is an anti semite and an IRA supporter, but he’s done some weird things considering.

Like when Islington Council, at the time led by Margaret Hodge, one of his accusers, wanted to sell the Jewish cemetery to property developers, and the notoriously anti semitic Corbyn worked with Jewish residents on a successful campaign to prevent that. Or when the notoriously Pro IRA Jeremy Corbyn met with former convicted UVF loyalist terrorist David Ervine to discuss the peace process.

Probably doesn’t mean anything significant, but it’s interesting to think about.

In 1945, Clement Attlee’s Labour Party won a general election, and began one of the most important projects in British history; the creation of the welfare state, a social safety net that ensured normal working people had access to the very basic things they needed.

They launched the national health service, providing taxpayer funded doctors, hospitals and medicine to everyone, free at the point of delivery. This is now so normal to them that they see it as the status quo.

They began an enormous housebuilding programme, which provided good quality houses, owned by local authorities, and rented to people on low incomes at affordable prices. Not only did this provide good quality housing to a lot of people, but it also held down housing prices and rents, because people who have an option for something more affordable will not swallow the kind of prices and rents do today.

They provided a system of employment rights and unemployment benefits so that you had security and decent treatment in your job, and could afford to live if you lost that job.

For the ensuing 75 years, the Tory party have been working with every ounce of their energy to remove all of those provisions. Social housing is more or less gone – Thatcher’s right to buy allied with a moratorium on spending the money from right to buy on new homes means that council housing stock has been massively depleted. They have a housing crisis, an overheated housing market meaning that those of them who can afford to own a house are paying many times more compared to wages than their parents or grandparents did, and stratospheric rents for properties which don’t legally have to be fit for human habitation.

Disability and unemployment benefits have been decimated, and Job Centre and PIP staff have targets to sanction or reject a certain proportion of applicants REGARDLESS OF THE VALIDITY OF THEIR CLAIMS.

Greens are anti-Brexit and want to see lots of improvements in EU policy that is currently damaging the environment. The UK has sacrificed its once science-based Department for Energy and Climate Change to make way for the Dept for Exiting the EU. There are justifications for severely criticising the EU’s environmental policies, but Brexit is driven by people and philosophies that are likely to exacerbate the problem.

0 0 vote
Article Rating
Help us grow. Support The Duran on Patreon!


The statements, views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of The Duran.

What do you think?

Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Roger Nixon
Roger Nixon
December 15, 2019

Corbyn is not an anti semite. What are you blabbering about?
“Corbyn wasn’t proposing state socialism. He was planning nationalisation of key natural monopolies only – power, water, post office, transport, and broadband.”
In your list, only water is a natural monopoly. The rest are man-made things. Land is a natural monopoly, the biggest and most solid, upon which humans live. What has Labour pledged to do about that? Nothing. Tax land, not man.

Reply to  Roger Nixon
December 17, 2019

Roger: the sentence about antisemitism and IRA was ironic sarcasm. This is suggested by the use of ” ” round ‘Everyone knows’. The writer goes on to explain why the statement is ironic by providing counter-examples.

Roger Nixon
Roger Nixon
Reply to  Coldish
December 18, 2019

If it was sarcasm, she’s horrible at it, since she concludes with this “Probably doesn’t mean anything significant, but it’s interesting to think about.”
Also, she didn’t provide counter-examples, as in more than one, to the AS charge, but ONE.

Morris Oxford
Morris Oxford
December 15, 2019

The UK is no longer a homogenous nation of communities or peoples. Any sense of a common history or shared values have been comprehensively destroyed for the purpose of turning UK PLC into a giant ‘labour camp’ that may be used to generate wealth for private equities in aeternum. The next five years of what will be unfettered hyper capitalism, will see the United Kingdom ‘strip mined’ for every conceivable asset that can be created out of thin air for the purpose of the upward transfer of wealth. Three days ago I gave a homeless man in Wandsworth high street… Read more »

December 15, 2019

in some ways Corbyn treated his enemies better than his friends — he and macdonald are the last two honourable people left in parliament –they didn’t expel all the Blairite traitors which they should have or denounce the Zionists which they should have — now they’re both going to decline the leadership, or resign which is an utterly honourable and totally stupid thing to do.

Reply to  buddha9
December 17, 2019

John McDonnell, not macdonald.

Darryl Secret
Darryl Secret
December 15, 2019

As soon as the lobby started to slander him, He should have gone “balls -to-the-wall” calling out the bigots of the Lobby at every chance he had, including presenting the Israeli/UK quid pro quo to get the U$A to enter the Great War.
I hope any other socialist leaning, Palestinian supporting candidate in other countries, doesn’t go the timid route to defend themselves… it’s not just the candidate; it’s the whole country and it’s citizens that need defending.

Reply to  Darryl Secret
December 17, 2019

Darryl: sadly I think you’re right. Politeness and civility don’t get you far against unscrupulous slander. Not when the MSM will just report the slander as fact while mocking your conciliatory attitude to the slander.

Exiled in Ard Mhaca
Exiled in Ard Mhaca
December 25, 2019

Being civil with the right wing MSM in Britain gets you nowhere. Corbyn should have went on the offensive from the get go. Changing the 2017 pledge on Brexit cost Labour big time not the policies.

No second referendum in Scotland

Who will pay the $250+ billion reconstruction cost in Syria?