in ,

How Much Is Tulsi Gabbard’s Reputation Worth?

Tulsi Gabbard’s defamation action against Hillary Clinton, which was filed last month, has provoked a mixed reaction. Die hard Clinton supporters and the very few who don’t like the Congresswoman from Hawaii regard her filing the suit with contempt. Everyone else believes it is justified.

We can for the moment ignore the quantum claimed, although Tulsi certainly looked like a million dollars when clad in that white suit she walked into the arena where she would demolish the Presidential aspirations of the odious Kamala Harris in spectacular fashion. The big question is, can she win this action? Unless it is settled before trial in her favour, the answer is probably no, for two reasons.

The first is that, although dating to 1964,  New York Times v Sullivan, still apparently the leading case for this type of defamation claim, severely restricts its scope for public figures. The second reason is by no means obvious. This is that while there is such a creature as a libel-proof plaintiff, Hillary Clinton has made herself a virtually libel-proof defendant. This needs some explanation.

Defamation is that which lowers a person’s reputation in the eyes of right thinking men and women. Traditionally, defamation actions have been expensive to bring, although ordinary people have at times sued successfully. For ordinary people, getting into print was either expensive or difficult. Every major media outlet had libel lawyers it could run dubious material by, and letters to the editor could be tailored to remove any possibly defamatory material.

The Internet and most especially social media has changed all that. YouTube, where the Clinton-Gabbard claim has been uploaded, is said to have up to 2 billion users, more than one person in four on the planet. That is staggering, and although not every YouTube user has a (Google) account, if only one person in a million posted one defamatory comment a year, that would be enough to keep every lawyer on Earth in court in perpetuity.

Some material posted to social media is grossly defamatory, indeed Hillary Clinton has herself been libelled many times, often in professionally crafted videos that claim she is an accessory to rape, at least one (certifiable lunatic of an) individual has accused her of actual rape, and many people take the Clinton Death List seriously. This list has now expanded to dozens of names, but ask  yourself how many 72 year olds a similar list could not be compiled about.

That aside, her pronouncements since losing out in 2016 have become tiresome and bizarre in equal measure. The causes of her losing that election have now run well into two if not three figures, indeed she has blamed everyone on planet Earth for Trump’s victory but herself. The claim that Trump colluded with Russia in some bizarre fashion started with her, it was she who financed the scurrilous Steele dossier. She and her cohorts also cheated Bernie Sanders. She branded half of Trump’s supporters as deplorables – irredeemable bigots – and has since branded Jill Stein and Heaven knows who else Russian agents, puppets, assets…

When he heard the audio of her smear on Tulsi, Bill Whittle summed her up in a nutshell: “Hillary Clinton is insane”.

To be libeled by a respected politician is one thing; to be libeled by a madwoman who lives in a fantasy world is another thing entirely. If this case does go to trial and Tulsi wins, the reader should expect only extremely modest damages, because no one with half a brain now takes anything Hillary Clinton says with anything but a grain of salt. Or maybe a boulder.

0 0 vote
Article Rating
Help us grow. Support The Duran on Patreon!

Report

The statements, views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of The Duran.

What do you think?

-1 points
Upvote Downvote
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
10 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
BobValdez
BobValdez
February 3, 2020

A boulder. A VERY LARGE boulder, dropped right on Killary’s ugly fucking head.

Tom Welsh
Tom Welsh
February 3, 2020

Nevertheless… Mrs Clinton is an ex-candidate for the Presidency and the wife of an actual ex-president. Perhaps almost half of US voters seem to believe in her and may even trust her. She is immensely influential.

Major Gabbard should win her suit and should be awarded huge damages – many millions at least.

Democracy Dies in Daftness
Democracy Dies in Daftness
Reply to  Tom Welsh
February 3, 2020

Sacrificial lambs, the whole lot of them. PC Bread & Circuses for the poor beasts.

oldandjaded
February 3, 2020

Bill Whittle is absolutely right Hillary is mentally ill, as is most of the US. Its interesting, and telling, that as someone who has subscribed to the narcissistic, hubristic self delusion that is Nietzscheism all her life, her life, and the nation, with the insane concept of “exceptionalism” forming its collective zeitgeist, has followed the same trajectory as Nietzsche’s life, ending with a descent into a paranoid, persecuted God complex.

Dr. Strangelove
Dr. Strangelove
Reply to  oldandjaded
February 3, 2020

Look, she started out her political career as a rootin’, tootin’ Goldwater cowgirl and hasn’t mentally changed one iota since. The roots reveal all.

Sacrificial Lamb
Sacrificial Lamb
February 3, 2020

Well, if she were Hillary C, then her ‘reputation’ would be worth billions, if calculated by the loss of contributions to her ‘fund’. But of course, she’s not Hillary C or I’d have to cast myself into the nearest volcano.

PS: democracy dies with sacrifice

Guy
Guy
February 3, 2020

Go Tulsi go. Though not American ,if I had my druthers ,Tulsi would be the next US president and the first female to do so. I have read too much about the Clintons to know better.Did not like her in 2016 and like her even less today .
Next best would be Bernie Sanders with Tulsi at his side.

oldandjaded
Reply to  Guy
February 5, 2020

With her CFR membership and financial and political ties to the RSS?

Vera Gottlieb
Vera Gottlieb
February 4, 2020

When till Hilary Clinton finally give up? She is a “has been” so time to step aside.

Nicholas Hazen
Nicholas Hazen
February 9, 2020

I hope Bernie picks Tulsi as his running mate.

Markle My Words – Taki’s Magazine

China Accuses US Of 'Inciting Panic' Over Coronavirus Outbreak