in ,

“Socialism Always Fails” is a Stupid Argument (Capitalism vs. Socialism, Sanctions, and History)

The statements, views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of this site. This site does not give financial, investment or medical advice.

 

In this video, I want to discuss socialism and the myth of capitalism. Like the YouTuber Hakim, whose video I posted, and Michael Parenti, I acknowledge the flaws in communism. We aren’t claiming it’s perfect. But unlike others, we strive to make a real analysis of this system and the Cold War. To this day, I haven’t found an analysis of the Cold War and communism’s so-called “failure” that considers the West’s control of 80% of the world’s wealth after WWII and the sanctions imposed on the Eastern Bloc, while also taking into account the U.S. abandoning the gold standard and creating the Petrodollar.

If the West and the U.S. didn’t cheat in their economic competition with the Communist bloc, why did they have to remove the gold standard? And how could the Communist bloc possibly compete with the U.S. and the West after the creation of the Petrodollar?

The U.S. cheated and lied in their economic competition against the Communist bloc. They printed more money than they were allowed to, but since their currency was the global reserve currency (being the only one backed by gold), the U.S. could print more dollars than normally permissible because global markets accepted part of those dollars as currency reserves in private and national banks. This created artificial demand, allowing the U.S. to print more currency than any other country, including the Communist ones.

However, the U.S. was limited by the gold standard. They couldn’t print more money than they had gold to back it up. After WWII, since the U.S. held around 80% of the world’s gold, this wasn’t initially a problem. But to print more money, they would eventually need either to increase their gold reserves or to reduce the exchange rate of dollars for gold. They did neither. Instead, without increasing gold reserves or adjusting the exchange rate, they simply printed dollars, ignoring the constraints.

Everything was fine until France called their bluff, sending warships to the U.S. with USD from French central bank reserves and demanding an exchange for gold. Since the U.S. didn’t have enough gold to back the dollars they had printed, their only option was to remove the gold standard. At that moment, the U.S. should have gone bankrupt, having cheated with their gold standard.

The U.S. faced a huge problem. For years, they had printed more dollars than their economy could support because the USD was a global reserve currency. Central and private banks around the world were holding about 60% of their currency reserves in USD, solely because of the gold standard. When the U.S. abandoned the gold standard, the USD lost its main advantage over other currencies. Central and private banks would naturally want to diversify their reserves into other currencies, potentially flooding the global market with excess dollars, leading to hyperinflation—a big problem for the U.S.

To solve this problem, they created the Petrodollar, forcing the world to buy oil in dollars, thus creating artificial demand for the USD, just as the gold standard had done. This prevented the hyperinflation that could have collapsed the U.S. economy.

I want to see analyze of Western and Soviet communist economies that consider everything I’ve mentioned. Recently, I heard something insightful in a video by Alex Christoforou:

 

15:16

“If Maduro is corrupt, a dictator, and doing such a bad job in Venezuela, there’s one way to find out if he’s really doing a terrible job. The only thing that the collective West has to do to expose Maduro for the incompetent dictator that he is, is to lift all the sanctions on Venezuela. That’s what the collective West could do in order to expose Maduro: lift all the sanctions.”

This highlights one of my main points: sanctions. It’s well explained in the main video I posted. I often hear people say, “Look at Cuba, look at Venezuela, look how poor they are; they even eat rats from hunger, and it’s all because of socialism.” Whenever I hear that, I get frustrated by the ignorance and ask them to name a socialist country that wasn’t sanctioned into oblivion by the West. I pose the same question Alex Christoforou just asked: if socialism is so bad and inefficient, why doesn’t the West remove sanctions from socialist countries and let them compete fairly against capitalist states? If socialism is so bad, wouldn’t they go bankrupt and fail anyway?

10:03

Let’s discuss failure. How would you define failure or collapse in this context? Did the Roman Empire fail? Did the numerous Portuguese republics fail? Terms need to be defined. To me, it sounds more like an emotional attack rather than an objective characterization. If capitalist countries with equally poor starting positions achieved the same level of development as socialist countries, despite all the hurdles artificially placed upon them, they’d be considered miracles. Similarly, when an average capitalist country like Bangladesh, Ecuador, or Kenya collapses due to political disorder, it’s never seen as a failure of capitalism. Instead, it’s attributed to corruption or some other vague explanation. It seems that only liberal democracies are spared from being considered failures.

Here’s some food for thought: The United States is the richest country on Earth and arguably in all of history, yet real wages have stagnated despite skyrocketing productivity. Most Americans can’t afford a $500 emergency. People are drowning in student and other debts. There’s no place in the U.S. where minimum wage workers can afford rent, and nearly half of Americans don’t earn enough to afford even a one-bedroom rental. Inflation is destroying savings, making the dream of homeownership an actual fantasy. Infrastructure is crumbling, income inequality is widening, and a climate catastrophe is looming. The American government supports every fascist tyrant and dictator. I could go on about rampant poverty, unemployment, homelessness, and serious issues with women’s rights.

People would rather die than go into medical debt. Stable employment and workers’ rights are regularly trampled in pursuit of profits, as we’ve seen in Ohio recently. School shootings and crumbling education—are these not failures? And this is without sanctions on the U.S., no foreign invasion, no internal sabotage—nothing. The American government has every privilege. It is the political, military, and economic hegemon. It regularly dictates the policy of other countries thousands of miles away to its own benefit. It dominates international trade through its currency and still fails to guarantee a respectable and dignified existence for all, or even most, of its citizens.

13:25

Unsurprisingly, this is the crux of the matter. The most minute negative aspect of a socialist country is not only magnified, but it’s also blown out of proportion or outright lied about, while the largest, most blatant positives are so heavily and unfairly—and in many cases incorrectly—scrutinized that their accomplishments are diminished, and their struggles are trivialized. Meanwhile, capitalist countries, usually wealthy Western ones, often get a pass.

I’ll give you an example: The East German secret police, the Stasi, is still spoken of in ill terms today—ironically, by Americans who live in houses practically bugged by numerous public and private agencies spying on their every word, move, and purchase. Every detail of their lives is intimately known. They will condemn the East Germans while ignoring their own peculiar situation. Of course, this doesn’t absolve the Stasi, but it should give you food for thought. You were told that East Germany was the height of totalitarianism, yet you live in a grotesque surveillance state and are told not to worry—as if you ever worried at all. If you’re interested in East Germany, take a look at the book Stasi State or Socialist Paradise? for a deeper dive.

Regardless, it’s a reproducible pattern. Some will condemn Soviet utilitarian housing blocks meant for temporary post-war housing while living in incredibly small apartments themselves, where two-thirds of their paychecks go towards rent, and homelessness is rampant. If you instantly recoil when hearing “Socialism” or “Communism,” ask yourself why. Maybe those that continuously villainize socialist ideas have a vested interest in keeping the population ignorant of the facts. But those who own everything, those with all the money—they would never lie, right?

Here’s also a great video explaining the myths of capitalism: 

I would argue that we’ve never had fair competition between socialism and capitalism. Communism didn’t fail because it was inefficient or worse than the capitalist system, but because of issues like those I mentioned, which are never considered in analyses of the economic failure of the Communist bloc. These include the capitalist West having 80% of the world’s wealth after WWII, the Communist bloc being destroyed during WWII (unlike the U.S.), the U.S. sanctioning the Communist bloc from day one, the U.S. cheating regarding the gold standard, and cheating again with the creation of the Petrodollar. I would love to see an economic analysis of the Capitalist and Socialist blocs that takes all these factors into account.

 

No-growth capitalism, as some of the more naive theorists have argued for, is a contradiction in terms. The reason for capitalism is to accumulate, and the accumulation of capital has no purpose unless you can mix it with labor to increase your wealth further. Large sums of capital are used not only for increasing wealth but also for personal consumption, political power, and control of culture, leading to that wonderful, happy life that many desire.

This nature of expansion is crucial because it means capitalism can never stay confined; it must go abroad. In the film Controlling Interest, a corporate president mentions that those corporations that remained regional in New England years ago and decided not to go national are now forgotten. Their names have faded because they didn’t expand. Those who went national realized they had to go international and invest abroad.

One of the laws of capital’s motion and development is inexorable expansion, which leads to the expropriation of the Third World—a process that has been ongoing for about 400 years, initially driven by the Portuguese, Spaniards, Dutch, Belgians, French, English, and more recently, most successfully, and most impressively, by the Americans. This expropriation has been carried out by the ruling classes of these countries, not by ordinary people. The ordinary people merely paid the costs of empire, sending their sons off to die on distant battlefields, in the jungles of the Congo, in Latin America, or elsewhere.

This brings us to another revelation: the Third World is not poor. You don’t go to poor countries to make money. There are very few poor countries in this world—most countries are rich. The Philippines, Brazil, Mexico, and Chile are rich countries, but it’s the people who are impoverished. However, for centuries, capitalist powers have carved up these nations, extracting resources like timber, oil, rubber, iron, and cheap labor. This relentless extraction has stifled their development and left them exploited.

 

BTW
Every time I ask someone defending capitalism to name a socialist country that wasn’t sanctioned, and they can’t, I ask them: Why do capitalist states sanction socialist countries? If they are so inefficient and bad, wouldn’t they go bankrupt and fail anyway? The only answer I usually get is, “Socialist countries are evil and treat their people badly, so we need to sanction them because they are evil.” That’s the only explanation they can come up with. I’m so happy to see people like Alex Christoforou understand this and start asking the same questions I do.

Report

The statements, views and opinions expressed in this column are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of this site. This site does not give financial, investment or medical advice.

What do you think?

17 Points
Upvote Downvote
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

58 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
The Holy Roman Führer.
August 17, 2024

“The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people’s money.”
― Margaret Thatcher

The Holy Roman Führer.
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 17, 2024

‘Ding, Dong, The Witch Is Dead‘, is how the English people fittingly celebrated Margaret Thatcher’s passing, but she hit the nail right on the head, with her quip about Socialism. 

Commit
Commit
Reply to  The Holy Roman Führer.
August 17, 2024

She started this financial ponzi scheme.

LillyGreenwood
LillyGreenwood
Reply to  Commit
August 17, 2024

Google is now paying $300 to $500 per hour for doing work online work from home. Last paycheck of me said that $20537 from this easy and simple job. Its amazing and earns are awesome. No boss, full time freedom and earnings are in front of you. This job is just awesome. Every person can makes income online with google easily….
.
M­­­­­­o­­­­­­r­­­­­­e­ D­­­­­­e­­­­­­t­­­­­­a­­­­­­i­­­­­­l­­­­­­s For Us→→→→ Www.Payathome9.Com

Last edited 2 years ago by LillyGreenwood
Commit
Commit
Reply to  The Holy Roman Führer.
August 17, 2024

I will not engage in this discussion but just look on debt rates of different countries.

The Holy Roman Führer.
Reply to  Commit
August 17, 2024

Debt rates is principal reason why we need to implement an Interest and Usury free monetary Policy, and a currency analogous to the Reichsmark, that the National Socialist German Workers’ Party (NSDAP) introduced. 

Last edited 2 years ago by The Holy Roman Führer.
Commit
Commit
Reply to  The Holy Roman Führer.
August 17, 2024

Capitalism is based on usury. There are no private banks in socialism. National socialists were originally socialists too. Dr Goebbels was praising Lenin in 1920s.

Last edited 2 years ago by Commit
MoT
MoT
Reply to  The Holy Roman Führer.
August 17, 2024

I see plenty of banks in ostensibly socialist countries. So how could that possibly work?

Commit
Commit
Reply to  MoT
August 17, 2024

Those are state owned banks.

The Holy Roman Führer.
August 17, 2024

“Communism didn’t fail because it was inefficient or worse than the capitalist system,….”

“Freedom is not free. Free men are not equal. Equal men are not free.” — Jerry Pournelle.

Last edited 2 years ago by The Holy Roman Führer.
penrose
penrose
August 17, 2024

Want a better world? Breed better people.

Which means selective breeding.

You don’t breed race horses by random nag shagging.

penrose
penrose
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 17, 2024

Now, there’s one thing you might have noticed. I don’t complain about politicians. Everybody complains about politicians. Everybody says they suck. Well, where do people think these politicians come from? They don’t fall out of the sky. They don’t pass through a membrane from another reality. They come from American parents and American families, American homes, American schools, American churches, American businesses and American universities, and they are elected by American citizens. This is the best we can do, folks. This is what we have to offer. It’s what our system produces: Garbage in, garbage out. If you have selfish,… Read more »

Last edited 2 years ago by penrose32
penrose
penrose
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 17, 2024

John Kennedy was a politician who made decisions.

Since Ronald Reagan? How about since Woodrow Wilson when the Khazars took over America starting with the Federal Reserve Bank.

KRA = Khazar Ruled America.

Commit
Commit
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 18, 2024

Socialism did not fail, it was growing and living standards were improving, just could not keep pace with the imperialist block in scientific and technological developments due to limited resources. 1989 counter revolutions were staged from above by intelligence services, it was deliberate decision made in Moscow in order to end the arms race they were afraid were losing.

This article contains many citations of Soviet generals, they needed to convince Americans to stop the arms race https://www.belfercenter.org/publication/power-globalization-and-end-cold-war-reevaluating-landmark-case-ideas

Last edited 2 years ago by Commit
The Holy Roman Führer.
August 17, 2024

Your whole Sanctions hypothesis for the failure of socialism is fallacious. 

Why? In the wake of Russia’s Special Military Operation in the former Ukraine, Russia is now by far the most-sanctioned country in the entire world, with 16,077 sanctions on Russian individuals and entities and Russia is thriving. 

The Holy Roman Führer.
Reply to  The Holy Roman Führer.
August 17, 2024

Statista —List of most sanctioned countries in the world as of December 15 2023;
1:Russia — 18772 
2:Iran — 4953
3:Syria — 2811
5:North Korea —2171
6:Belarus —1454
7:Venezuela —747

Last edited 2 years ago by The Holy Roman Führer.
The Holy Roman Führer.
Reply to  The Holy Roman Führer.
August 17, 2024

Checkmate! Grzegorz Ochman.

Last edited 2 years ago by The Holy Roman Führer.
The Holy Roman Führer.
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 17, 2024

Socialism is unworkable, because it an unrighteous system based on the antithesis of Natural law, as one of the first words a child naturally learns is mine!

Last edited 2 years ago by The Holy Roman Führer.
The Holy Roman Führer.
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 17, 2024

An analogy of Socialism. 

Take a Classroom of 30 students, and divided the students grades by 30, to come to an average mark (Equality).

Why would the A grade students even bother any longer, when their average mark is going to be a D grade, which will eventually slip down to an E and then an F, when nobody can be bothered any longer, because of unnatural Equality. 

penrose
penrose
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 17, 2024

One influence they have is to force the sanctioned nations to become more independent and self-reliant, thus not forced to behave like subservient vassals of the sanctioners.

penrose
penrose
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 17, 2024

There is short term and there is long term.
Short term pain may lead to long term gain.
Thus the saying: “What does not destroy me makes me stronger”

The Holy Roman Führer.
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 17, 2024

Venezuela has the largest oil reserves in the world, and could easily have built the largest Oil Tanker fleet in the world, (with anti ship missiles to protect their fleet) and they could supply all of the Asian nations with Oil, and the country would then become self-sufficient with its abundant natural resources, which include gas, iron ore, gold, bauxite, diamonds and other minerals.

Instead, Venezuela it is becoming a failed state, because of its idiotic socialist policies.

The Holy Roman Führer.
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 17, 2024

Elementary. Do a deal with the Asian nations (especially China), for long-term contractual access to the embarrassment of riches in Venezuela, which includes the largest oil reserves in the world, coupled with their vast mineral reserves, which includes aluminium, iron, bauxite, gold, diamonds and their natural gas.

The Asian nations will then supply Venezuela with an armada of oil tankers, transport ships and military escort, and Venezuela could then implement a long term barter system, circumventing the Empires financial system. 

Last edited 2 years ago by The Holy Roman Führer.
The Holy Roman Führer.
Reply to  The Holy Roman Führer.
August 17, 2024

Venezuela would then have a Political, Economic and Military alliance with China and other Asian Nations, and they could then slowly build their country into a self sufficient nation. 

Last edited 2 years ago by The Holy Roman Führer.
The Holy Roman Führer.
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 17, 2024

The Monroe Doctrine is a relic of a bygone era, and it obviously has no relevance in the 21st century, as the vast majority of the United States military, is made up of 20th century technology, including its archaic Aircraft Carriers, which have been made impotent by Russian, Chinese and now Iranian hypersonic missiles. 
Anyway, do you seriously think the United States, Diversity, equity and inclusion LGBTQ army, would have the balls to invade Venezuela? 

Last edited 2 years ago by The Holy Roman Führer.
Luke
Luke
August 17, 2024

I glazed over a lot of this and not because it’s bad but because I’m tired of reading genius absent will. I learn so much and yet somehow understand less than I did.

Who are you, Gregorz? Do a show with the lads. The world needs you. Stop letting idiots take the mic and/or stifling geniuses / yourself.

Arthur
Arthur
August 17, 2024

“Socialism is great!”

“Buy VPN from my sponsor!”

If the worker’s paradises were so wonderful, why did people have to be kept in them by force? Which country built the Berlin Wall, and posted armed guards to prevent people from leaving?

Arthur
Arthur
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 18, 2024

Straw man.

Sure, armed guards are needed to keep people in places they want to stay. And that Stalin, such a nice man. Solzhenitsyn just made up all those stories about the gulag to get rich.

The Holy Roman Führer.
Reply to  Arthur
August 18, 2024

You really need to read the three Volumes of The Gulag Archipelago, and not the shorter abridged version (472 pages), to fully understand the pure demonic evil of the Judeo-Soviet Gulag system. 

The Gulag Archipelago 
volume 1 (I-II) 671 pages, 
volume 2 (III-IV) 717 pages, 
volume 3 (V-VII) 579 pages.

A free copy on pdf is available on the Internet Archive.

Commit
Commit
Reply to  Arthur
August 17, 2024

People who receive free education should not be allowed to leave unless they pay all expenses back. I am all for re-erecting walls if only for these cases.

Commit
Commit
Reply to  Commit
August 17, 2024

Who needs to cross borders anyway. Traveling abroad will require submitting to vaccine pass and other nonsense in future.

penrose
penrose
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 17, 2024

Like all of the American Students who didn’t pay back their student loans? And they were right in America, not off in another country.

Commit
Commit
August 17, 2024

If China imposed embargo on the USA, they would literally return to stone age.

Commit
Commit
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 17, 2024

Domestic consumption won’t fix much. China needs exports in order to earn for importing essential commodities, mainly oil and iron ore at this point I believe. But they are decreasing exports to USA and increasing to other countries. At one point US market will become irrelevant.

G2mil
August 17, 2024

Most Americans are confused when I tell them 30-40% of the American economy is socialist. Most schools, police and fire departments, prisons, libraries, roads, airports, the military, veteran’s health care, social security, welfare.

penrose
penrose
Reply to  Grzegorz Ochman
August 17, 2024

You certainly got that right!

MoT
MoT
August 17, 2024

I’m against all forms of governmental nannyism and infantalism no matter whether it’s cloaked as “capitalism” or “socialism”. The fact is there are people who can’t control themselves when it comes to being in charge. They’re power hungry megalomaniacs, and do-gooders, who, “for the good of the people”, want to RULE over you and tell you what to do. And as long as they exist there will always be strife.

Last edited 2 years ago by MoT
penrose
penrose
Reply to  MoT
August 17, 2024

Ah yes. For example, America is a Government of the People, by the People, and for the Psychopaths

penrose
penrose
August 18, 2024

“How Hitler Defied The International Bankers” Under the National Socialists, Germany’s money wasn’t backed by gold (which was owned by the international bankers). It was essentially a receipt for labor and materials delivered to the government. Hitler said, “For every mark issued, we required the equivalent of a mark’s worth of work done, or goods produced.” The government paid workers in Certificates. Workers spent those Certificates on other goods and services, thus creating more jobs for more people. In this way the German people climbed out of the crushing debt imposed on them by the international bankers. At that point… Read more »

Last edited 2 years ago by penrose32
zapster
zapster
August 18, 2024

The thing is, the US never was limited by the gold standard. That was why Nixon ditched it–it had *already* printed far more than it had gold to back it up. And that is a historical norm. No country ever refrained from a war because it didn’t have enough gold. What it had was resources that hadn’t been bombed to smithereens, and that is what matters.

zapster
zapster
August 18, 2024

Excellent report.

Western Kosovo Meta-Mythology and Serbian Ethnology-history  

European leaders escalate war rhetoric with Iran